Document Type : Research Paper
Author
Assist.Prof.
Abstract
Introduction Tillage is a main operation for seedbed preparation and is one of the major items of energy and cost expenditure in crop production. In the conventional rotary tillers, using the L-shape blades has numerous problems such as severe vibrational problems, weeds wrapping around the blades, and lower performance due to the limited power of such small tillers. Therefore in order to overcome the addressed problems, design, fabrication and evaluation of a new rototiller adapted for small farms and gardens were considered in this research.
Materials and Methods To start the design, the power requirement was estimated using a semi-theoretical model for the given working depth, working width, forward and rotational speed of the machine. Then a suitable engine was chosen based on the estimated power. The estimated power was 3.4 kW (4.5 hp); therefore, according to the available engines in the market for single cylinder gasoline engines, a Kato engine with 5.5 hp power and maximum speed of 3600 rpm was chosen. By reducing the rotational speed of the engine in three stages, rotational speed of the rotor was obtained in the range of 140-260 rpm. To transmit the power from the engine to the rotary axis, first, a pulley and belt mechanism (two V-shaped belt, type B) and then two chain mechanisms (roller chains 40 and 60) were used. Rotary axis with the diameter of 2.5 cm was made from steel E295. The fabricated rototiller has a working width of 60 cm, working depth of 7 cm, rotational speed between 140-260 rpm, forward speed equal to the operator’s translational speed, and maximum power equal to 5.5 hp.
The maximum force exerted on each of the blades was calculated equal to 84.10 kgf (824.73 N) using the theoretical approach proposed by Bernacki (1972). In the next step, numerical simulation of blades, flanges and rotating shaft for stress and strain analysis was performed using the Ansys software.
Farm experiments were carried out as split plots in citrus gardens based on randomized complete block design with three replications. The soil moisture content as the main plot varied in two levels (13.5-21.9 and 21.9-30.3 percent based on dry weight) and the rotational speed of blades as subplots varied in three levels (140-170, 170-200 and 200-230 rpm).
The measured parameters consisted of clod mean weight diameter, soil relent percentage, soil bulk density and specific fuel consumption. To determine the diameter of aggregates, a set of standard sieves with the diameter ranging from 0.5 to 8 mm were used. Then a laboratory shaker was used to sift the samples. Each sample was shaken for 30 sec. To determine the fuel consumption during the experiments, the filled fuel tank method was used. Data analyses including analysis of variance (Anova), mean comparisons and interaction between the parameters were performed using the SPSS 16 software.
Results and Discussion The numerical stress analysis of the flange showed that the maximum van - Mises stress occurred in the position of the blade-flange connections, with a magnitude of 52.98 MPa for the given working conditions, including soil engineering properties, working depth and other important parameters. The experimental results obtained in this study indicated that influence of soil moisture and rotational speed of blades on the clod mean weight diameter, soil relent percentage and specific fuel consumption were significant (p < 0.01). The clod mean weight diameter was measured equal to 8 mm at high rotational speed (200-230 rpm) and high soil moisture content (21.9%-30.3%) and equal to 15 mm at low rotational speed (140-170 rpm) and low soil moisture content (13.5%- 21.9%). The maximum soil relent percentage was obtained equal to 97% at high rotational speed (200-230 rpm) and high soil moisture content (21.9%-30.3%).
Regarding the results obtained in this study, the specific fuel consumption increased first in a light slop, then in a steep rise with increasing the blades rotational speed. The reason can be the higher relent percent of the soil at higher rotational speeds and higher moisture contents, albeit at the examined range of 21.9-30.3. The specific fuel consumption was maximum at higher soil moisture content, i.e., 30 %. The results indicated that the blades rotational speed and soil moisture content had no significant effect on the field efficiency of the examined rototiller. Reduction of the rotational speed of the rototiller from high-to-moderate speeds yields decreasing the fuel consumption of 17 liter/ha, which could be significant in a wide scale soil tillage operations. As a general result, reduction of the rotational speed has some considerable advantages such as reducing the power requirements, reducing the blade wearing and maintaining the soil structure.
Conclusion The stress analysis of the fabricated machine together with the experimental and field measurements indicated that the new proposed and fabricated blades were a suitable choice for construction of small rototillers. The fabricated machine with the new blades showed some additional advantages including less specific energy consumption, less weeds wrapping around the blades, and less vibrational problems.
Keywords
Main Subjects
- Arvidsson, J. and Bolenius, E. 2006. Effects of soil water content during primary tillage – laser measurements of soil surface changes. Soil and Tillage Research, 90: 222-229.
- ASME Standard B29.1M, 1993. Precision Power Transmission Roller Chains, Attachments, and Sprockets, The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 345 E.47th St., New York, NY.
- Bernacki, H., Haman, J., and Kanafojski, C. Z. 1972. Agricultural machines, theory and construction, US department of Agriculture and national science foundation. Washington. D.C.
- Berntsen, R., and Berre, B. 1993. Fract uring of soil clods and the soil crumbling effectiveness of draught tillage implements. Soil and Tillage Research, 28: 79-94.
- Borghei, A.M. 2006. Machine Elements (Translation). Publication and Print Institute of Tehran University. Tehran.
- Dewangan, K. N., and Tewari, V. K. 2009. Characteristics of hand-transmitted vibration of a hand tractor used in three operational modes. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 39: 239-245.
- Gardner, W. R. 1956. Representation of soil aggregate -size distribution by a logarithmic-normal distribution. Soil Science Society of America Proceeding, 20: 151-153.
- Gouran Oreymi, M., and A. R. Keyhani. 2010. Effects of tractor velocity and soil moisture content on drive wheel slippage of tractor. The 6th National Conference on Agricultural Machinery Engineering and Mechanization. College of Agriculture and Natural Resources of University Of Tehran, Karaj, Iran. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Habibi Asl, J., and Gilani, A. A. 2014. Effect of Tillage method and rice cultivation on machine parameters, yield and yield components of wheat and residue management for Rice-Wheat rotation in Khuzestan. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 15:45-62. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Hemmat, A. and Asadi Khashoei, A. 1995. Fuel requirements and machine capacity for tillage andplanting operations on a clay loam soil in Isfahan, Iran Agricultural Research, 14(2): 175-201. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Hendrick, J. G. and Gill, W. R. 1971. Rotary tiller design parameters. Part I direction of rotation, Transactions of the ASAE. 14 (4): 669–683.
- Jacobs, C. O. and Harrel, W. R. 1983. Agricultural power and machinery. McGraw Hill Book Co. NewYork.
- Kalantari, D. A. 2013. Mathematical model for estimation of rotary tiller power requirement. World of Sciences Journal, 1:86-93.
- Kepner, R. A., Bainer, E. L. and Barger, E. L. 1972. Principle of Farm Machinery Second ED, West Port Connecticut, The AVI publishing Co, INC, 168 p.
- Komarizadeh, M.H. 2007. Tractor mechanic and agricultural machines. Urmia University Jihad Publications. Urmia. Iran. 170 P.
- Kouchakzadeh, A. and Haghighi, K. 2011. The effect of rototiller equipped with serrated blades on some soil properties. International Research Journal of Applied and Basic Sciences, 2(6): 209-215.
- Lee, K. S., Park, S. H., Park, W. Y., and Lee, C. S. 2003. Strip tillage characteristics of rotary tiller blades for use in dryland direct rice seeder. Soil and Tillage Research Journal, 71: 25-32.
- Loghavi, M., and Behnam, S. 1998. Effects of soil moisture and tillage depth on disk plow performance of a clay loam soil. Water and Soil Science (Journal of Science and Technology of Agriculture and Natural Resources) 2(4): 105-117. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Matin, M.A., Fielke, J. M., and Desbiolles, J. M. A. 2014. Furrow parameters in rotary strip-tillage, Effect of blade geometry and rotary speed. Biosystems Engineering. 118: 7-15.
- Mollazade, K. and Riahi, R. 2008. Simulation and analysis of mechanical three types of rotary plow blade using finite element software (Ansys). The 5th National Congress of Agricultural Machinery Engineering and Mechanization. Iran Association of Agricultural Engineering and Mechanization. Mashhad. Iran. (in Farsi).
- Nasr, H. M., and Selles, F. 1995. Seedling emergence as influenced by aggregate size, bulk density and penetration resistance of the seedbed. Soil and Tillage Research, 34: 61-67.
- Perfect, E. and Kay, B. D. 1994. Statistical characterization of dry aggregate strength using rupture energy, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 58: 1804-1809.
- Rajabi Vandechali, M., Hemmat, A. and Ghanbari Malidareh, A. 2015. Field performance of the disk harrow, power harrow and rotary tiller at different soil moisture contents on a clay loam soil in Mazandaran. Journal of Agricultural Machinery Engineering, 5: 63-72. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Reshad sedghi, A. and Loghavi, M. 2009. The effect of soil moisture content (in primary tillage) and travel speed during disking operation on performance of disk harrow as a secondary tillage tool. Iranian Journal of Biosystems Engineering (Iranian Journal of Agricultural Sciences), 40 (2): 131-138. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Roozbeh, M., Almasi, M. and Hemmat, A. 2002. Evaluation and comparison of energy requirements in different tillage methods for corn production. Journal of Agricultural Science and Natural Resources, 9(1): 117-128. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Russel, E. W. 1965. Soil Conditions and Plant Growth, Longmans Green and Co. Ltd., London. 384 p.
- Saimbhi, V. S., Wadhwa, D. S., and Grewal, P. S. 2004. Development of a Rotary Tiller Blade using Three-dimensional Computer Graphics, Biosystems Engineering, 89(1): 47–58.
- salokhe, V. M. and Ramalingam, N. 2001.Effects of direction of rotation of a rotary tiller on properties of Bangkok clay soil. Soil and Tillage Research, 63: 65-74.
- Sedghi, R., and Abbaspur-gilandeh, Y. 2014. Factors affecting soil fragmentation during tillage practice and determining the optimal range of the parameters using a fuzzy logic approach. Scientific Journal of Agriculture, 37: 35-47. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Shafiei, S. A. 1995. Tillage machines.University Publication Center. Tehran.
- Shir Esmailie, Gh. H., and M. Heidari Soltanabadi. 2009. Effect of tillage systems and seeding rates on machinery parameters and grain yield in rapeseed (BrassicanapusL.). Iranian Journal of Crop Sciences, 11(3): 223-236. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Singh, G. 1983. Optimal energy for tillage tools, Unpublished M Tech Thesis, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, 1983.
- Spotts, M. F. Shoup, T. E. and Hornberger, L. E. 2004. Design of Machine Elements, Volume 2. Pearson/Prentice Hall.
- Tabatabae Koloor, R., and Kiani. Gh. 2011. Investigation of the rototiller blades operational factors on the orchards and paddy fields tillage. Journal of Agricultural Machinery Engineering, 1(1): 34-40. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Valinejad, A. 2008. Tabellenbuch metal (Translation). Tarrah Publication. Tehran. Iran.
- Younesi Alamouti, M. and Sharifi, A. 2012. Study and Determining Power, Fuel Requirements and Some Soil Physical Properties in Several Tillage Methods. Journal of Agricultural Machinery Engineering, 2(1): 11-18. (in Persian with English abstract).
- Zareiforoush, H. Komarizadeh, M.H., and Alizadeh, M.R. 2010. Rotary Tiller Design Proportional to a Power Tiller using Specific Work Method (SWM). Nature and Science, 8:(9) 39-45,
- Zareiforoush, H., Komarizadeh, M.H., Vesali, F. and Vesali, F. 2008. Rotary Tiller design fits with garden tractor OTM 930 model. The 5th National Congress of Agricultural Machinery Engineering and Mechanization. Iran Association of Agricultural Engineering and Mechanization. Mashhad. Iran. (in Persian).
- Zhang, Z. X., and. Kushwaha, R. L. 1999. Application of neural network to simulate soil-tool interaction and soil behavior. Canadian Agricultural Engineering, 41: 119-125